The TSA, an organization designed to maintain security in transportation - an organization that has been the greatest threat to the security of individuals attempting to travel to, from or through the United States for the last few years, has started a blog. Their tagline reads: “Terrorists Evolve. Threats Evolve. Security Must Stay Ahead. You Play A Part.”
While I applaud their support of the theories of evolution I think they’re still on the wrong side of the fence, and I’m not the only one if their blog post replies are any standard worth noting. This blog is a step in the right direction, but they’re still barking up the wrong Bush on most accounts when it comes to international security.
[Speaking of which, if you’re in Reykjavík, I recommend Alyson Baile’s course on international security at the University of Iceland, Wednesdays at 13:20, Oddi room 201]
Terrorists do evolve. Their techniques change to suit the purposes. But terrorism is related to ideology. One of the best ways to reduce terrorism is to stop imposing conflicting ideologies - freedom isn’t reserved for people with the right mindset.
Threats do evolve. But anybody can make threats, and anybody can follow through on them. Not just terrorists. I can threaten to eat one of my nephews. I probably won’t do it. But I could. Is that reason enough to knock my teeth out and deny me access to knives?
Security must stay ahead. I totally agree. But security cannot and must not be pushed ahead at the expense of personal freedoms. If you’re using restrictions to apply security, you’re doing it wrong. (This likewise to people who do computer security: blocking ports doesn’t increase security - you only need one open port to get in. However, educating your users might get you a long way).
We do play a part. Security isn’t the TSA’s problem. It’s everbody’s problem. And if everybody thinks clearly, acts rationally, and works together, we can fulfill TSA’s mandate several thousand orders of magnitude better, at no cost, and without touching on people’s freedom to travel.
On my arrival in New York last August I had to stand in line for the better part of an hour before being fingerprinted. This was the height of the unpleasantness I had to endure, and am fairly glad of that, because after reading several accounts of people being strip-searched, illegally imprisoned and even tasered to death, I expected the worst coming to somebody such as myself who has the damned insolence to openly criticize this kind of behavior. I will be going to New York again later this month, and I very much hope I’ll be treated fairly.